A client running a hybrid studio around Logic Pro needed to send MIDI to a number of hardware synths, so I recommended 5-pin DIN MIDI rather than USB, because in my experience USB MIDI isn’t tight enough on timing once lots of synths are playing together.
He routes audio through a number of boutique hardware synths and other outboard boxes, and the question was how to distribute MIDI around the system so that everything plays back in time. I’d first worked with him in a remote session where we went through an audit of his equipment and talked about the problems he was having with his setup. Those problems came directly from using the USB MIDI built into each of his synths.
Why I avoid USB MIDI for a lot of synths
If you run 12 synths into a Mac with 12 different MIDI to USB solutions, whether that’s external converter boxes like a MIDISport or the USB MIDI built into the synths themselves, which most come with these days as a convenience for the user, my experience is that the timing isn’t tight. There are micro differences and delays in timing which can completely ruin the intended playback of the music, and it’s not something a composer should be experiencing.
With a couple of synths in a track you can hear the MIDI working and you’re kind of happy. It’s when you have five or even 10 or 15 different bits of hardware playing at once that you need rock solid timing, otherwise everything drifts and sounds awful.
How I settled on the mioXL
I came to my solution by trial and error, from working in lots of different studios, and in particular with one client who would accept absolutely no compromise on timing. We tried a few different solutions, and the one we found worked was a dedicated iConnectivity MIDI interface running 5-pin DIN. For a larger studio the device I use is the iConnectivity mioXL, which has 12 DIN ports. That was enough for his setup, and if a studio needed more than 12 I wouldn’t be worried about adding more iConnectivity devices.
Getting DIN 9 to 12 to show up
I don’t usually recommend that people buy things, but in that remote session I recommended a mioXL to him, because he would definitely benefit from a dedicated MIDI interface. It made sense to him, and I could make the recommendation confidently because I’d seen it working in other studios myself. When I came to his studio on site, he had the mioXL and we got it working. There’s one technical challenge on that unit that isn’t obvious. DIN ports 9 to 12 on the front aren’t available in the DAW’s MIDI routing. It only shows DIN 1 to 8, and then the USB host ports.
The solution is to connect the mioXL by USB, which he had done anyway, and download iConnectivity’s Auracle software, which lets you change the internal routing of the device. In Auracle you can switch host outputs 1 to 4 from going to USB to going to the DIN ports instead. If you’d rather not do it yourself, I also offer setting up the mioXL’s DIN ports for you as a service.
- Host 1 to DIN 9.
- Host 2 to DIN 10.
- Host 3 to DIN 11.
- Host 4 to DIN 12.
You can rename the ports in Auracle if you want, but I didn’t bother, because we were setting up the synths as external devices in macOS Audio MIDI Setup and naming them there. DIN 9 was still labelled Host 1 inside the mioXL, but in Audio MIDI Setup it was connected to one of his synths, so we gave it that synth’s name and that’s how it appeared in Logic. There was no need to go through the internal naming, which the user was never going to see.
On the mioXL, DIN 9 to 12 only become available in Logic once you remap host outputs 1 to 4 to them in Auracle.
I’m not sure why iConnectivity decided not to make those DIN ports accessible by default. It isn’t an impossible workaround, but it can throw users who aren’t expecting it and expect the device to be plug and play.
I wouldn’t let that configuration step put anyone off buying an iConnectivity interface for an advanced MIDI setup. In my opinion it’s the most solid brand around for this type of work, and I’ve installed it in many studios. If one of your hardware synths ignores the notes Logic sends it, I’ve also written up a case about a TB-03 that ignored notes from Logic because of its MIDI channel.
If several hardware synths drift against each other on playback, try sending them 5-pin DIN from one dedicated MIDI interface instead of a separate USB MIDI connection for each synth.
Not sure it’s the same problem? Ask a question first
