A composer and producer asked me whether he should upgrade macOS on his 2017 iMac Pro so he could update Safari, and I advised him to leave the system as it was, because his studio was running well and he was in the middle of a project.
His iMac Pro was his main studio computer for composing and recording music, running High Sierra (macOS 10.13.6) with Logic Pro, various plugins, an audio interface and microphones. He was recording commercial projects and working with session singers who came into his studio. At this point everything was running well. He wasn’t getting any error messages, his recordings were clean, he had a backup system in place and nothing on the system was running slowly.
The problem that had come up was Safari. It was no longer displaying websites correctly, and he’d been told he couldn’t update it because it was no longer compatible with his Mac. There were also plugins he had paid for but couldn’t use on the old operating system. He’d been putting off an upgrade because Logic and all his third-party software were nice and stable, but he felt he needed to do it now, while an upgrade was still possible on his iMac Pro. As an active musician and producer he knew about new developments in music technology and wanted to be able to take advantage of some of them. So his question for me was whether he could upgrade his operating system, then Safari, and possibly Logic Pro and his plugins to newer versions.
He’d worked with me before, and he contacted me for my opinion because he knew I’d seen people upgrade their systems and run into problems. We spoke by phone, as AnyDesk wouldn’t run on High Sierra.
Why I advised against upgrading
In short, I didn’t recommend upgrading his operating system any further while his computer was running Logic Pro smoothly and he was able to record his clients. The first reason was that he told me he was in the middle of a project. Being in the middle of a project is never a good time to upgrade your system. I’ve been contacted by so many clients with deadlines because of exactly that situation, and I’m glad I was able to stop him making that mistake.
The second reason was that he was running an Intel iMac Pro.
Apple’s own software, including Logic Pro, and the third-party plugins released over the last five years have been written for Apple silicon Macs and the versions of macOS optimised for them.
In my experience there have been a lot of cases of clients running Intel Macs where I’ve had to go through a lot of troubleshooting steps to get them working properly. With some, I’ve had to tell the client that sadly they have been left behind by Apple. Their systems slow down, error messages pop up, and they get caught in an upgrade spiral where things stop working, until a pop-up tells them their computer won’t accept the latest software and they are forced to buy new equipment. This makes business sense for Apple. They want people to upgrade their Macs and buy new equipment, and they don’t want people to leave their legacy systems running, because that makes no business sense for them.
If he did upgrade and found incompatibilities, he’d be facing either a rollback, which Apple hasn’t made easy, or seeking out legacy updates for his plugins, which would probably take time and lead to no benefit for him. I’ve been in situations before where we’ve tried updating something, and all it’s done is cause problems and use up more technical support time just to fix what the update broke.
Working around the Safari problem
Instead, I recommended he leave his system in place and deal with the other problems around it.
- Move his web browsing from Safari to Chrome. Google stopped updating Chrome for High Sierra after version 116 in 2023, so on that system it no longer gets updates.
- If webmail gave him trouble, use it in Chrome or download a mail client. In my experience a 2018 mail client was still working fine with a 2026 online mailbox.
- If something like Dropbox stopped working on the old system, he may need to change how he transfers music off it.
The Chrome workaround did the job. The version of Chrome we downloaded displayed the websites he needed, and he could get to his mail in it, which was enough to get him through the project. I’m aware Chrome has stopped being updated for High Sierra too, so we may only be delaying the problem, but delaying it until he’d finished his album was a lot better than opening up the can of worms an operating system upgrade would have caused.
If he needs a computer for admin as well as music, it might be worth getting a newer Mac or possibly a cheap Windows PC, or moving his admin to an iPad, his phone or another computer if he has one available. That way he can keep his studio computer as a legacy device, running as a standalone music machine.
If your studio Mac is recording reliably and you’re mid-project, try solving the side problems, like the browser, around it before you touch the operating system.
Not sure it’s the same problem? Ask a question first
